Alex Romanenko

Your work is really very good for me and I congratulate you on it, a hug

Your work excites me and it will be a reference for me, I congratulate you

your work deserves all my admiration and I congratulate you for it, a hug

Dmitry Prikhodko,
I expected something like this nonsense from you.

Andrew Kud, well, I didn't expect anything from you at all after looking at your portfolio, which doesn't contain a single photograph. Which means, most likely, you're incapable of even thinking.

I agree, it was my mistake to respond to you before looking at your "works." Which, I suppose, all of them have, as you call it,

EXPRESSIVE composition

Composition, Andrey, is the author's statement. The meaning and spirit embedded in the work.

Dmitry Prikhodko,
I expected something like this nonsense from you.

Dmitry Prikhodko,
Reading the comments feed from newcomers to the FC, this is the third time today I've encountered criticism of "composition" in various images.
Dmitry, would you mind explaining what you mean by this mysterious term?
I would be very grateful for a sensible (finally!!!!!!!) explanation.

Andrew Kud, Composition, Andrey, is the author's statement. The meaning and spirit embedded in the work. They are what distinguish a genuine work from a fake. By the way, don't confuse the genuine with the relevant. For only the genuine is relevant. )) The rest is the insinuation of activists and businessmen.

Thousands of paintings hang on the walls of museums. How can one distinguish the genuine from a craft? How can one distinguish a composition from an arrangement? By what the artist intended and what the viewer (even if not everyone) perceives. By the spiritual energy emanating from the canvas, transforming both the viewer and reality.

The Son of God within the lines of the sacrificial bowl in Rublev's Trinity—that's composition. And arranging the horizon in thirds is, at best, arrangement. In the ordinary sense, it's a template. The volumes, brightness, colors, contrasts, and lines have been well-arranged—okay, we've achieved harmony. But not composition.

A complex and ambiguous question.

Alexander Zeonoff, This is only for those who, having picked up the basics from less-than-competent sources, haven't spent any time realizing that the common definition of this term is practically nonsense. And nothing more.
***
For example, I see a CLEAR composition in this picture.
And why Prikhodko doesn't see it, we'll hopefully learn from his revelations

Taurus49, composition? Where is it here?)

Dmitry Prikhodko, A complex and ambiguous question. It would indeed be interesting to hear your opinion.

Dmitry Prikhodko,
Reading the comments feed from newcomers to the FC, this is the third time today I've encountered criticism of the "composition" in various images.
Dmitry, would you mind explaining what you mean by this mysterious term?
I would be very grateful for a sensible (finally!!!!!!!) explanation.

I like the light and shadow accents, the rendering of space, the composition, and the image itself!

Taurus49, the composition? Where is it here?

I like the light and shadow accents, the rendering of space, the composition and the image itself!

Like it

Gorgeous light! And the smoke is spot on!

your photographs are the closest thing to a work of art, congratulations

You have very good taste in taking pictures and I congratulate you on it, best regards

Нравится! Рекомендую!!

cool

ОСЕНЬ! Отличный снимок! Удачи!

beautiful

Глаза!!!

В ч/б у вас очень хорошие работы!

"В тёплом проёме".... "Прижаться к вечному, оствить "след"...

Контраст работает...

Good

great

Странная поза.

Красивые работа и модель.

попробуйте)

надо было муку и яйцы на модель намазать и назвали бы фото пельмень :))

Like

Excellent portrait

Что с бровями? Кто рисовал? Гнать в шею! )

тож понравилось

cool

"... вот такие Мы!"

Красавица! Похожа на мою Рейнальду в юности.

Отличо!

Модель великолепна...

Холодно ей, небось?!

Завал - ракурсные издержки. Можно просто слегка трансформировать...

Понравилось. Только есть ощущение завала вправо - правый край очень тяжелый. Надо бы слева захватить чуть больше.

Удивительно! Получилось нечто музыкальное....

"Комо грядеши?"

Ver recorte многовато слева:((

Cool

Симпатичная карточка.

Excellent, it's a pity the rivers are gone!:)

It feels like someone stuck it in the sand with their feet, like a porcelain figurine. And it's the gnomon of a sundial. All that's left is to mark the dial.

Alexandr Popov, that's the idea.

By the way, it's cool! )

Excellent! /I would only make the light and shadow drawing - the foreground - the same as in the background/